christie downs testimony transcript
851 (quoting McCleskey v. Zant, 499 U.S. 467, 494, 111 S.Ct. Things have continued to go up for Christie Downs, as The Sun states she welcomed her first son in 2005 before welcoming a daughter years later who has been named in honor of Cheryl. Thankfully, it was granted, and he could continue to treat the youngster. Robert was already married with children, meaning the couple had to embark on a secret affair. In addition, Pond did retain reports on certain people who eventually became defense witnesses and he appears to have incorporated many of his notes into various reports, some of which Downs received. Decades have passed, but the effects of that day still seem to live with Danny. See Transcript of the Record, Volume 2 of 2 at 9. 2052, 80 L.Ed.2d 674 (1984). Christie Downs was called as a witness to testify against her mother. However, Diane will never be allowed out of prison if certain people have their way. We are a welcoming and caring place that offers social, recreational and educational activities. Public Health Committee. He came in the form of Robert Knickerbocker, but there were several issues. One of the many harsh realities plenty have faced is that things dont always work out like they do in the movies. Because the claim was fairly presented to the state court and nothing indicates that it was rejected on an independent state ground, it is properly before us. First, as you just read . The prosecution argued it was all a bid for Diane to try and continue her affair with Robert Knickerbocker. The question is not whether the verdict would more likely than not have been different, but whether the defendant received a fair trial, understood as a trial resulting in a verdict worthy of confidence. Ending Cheryls life meant Diane was being charged with taking someones life. . Rebecca also admitted she wrote to her biological mom when she was younger. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. The final set of transcripts, exhibits, and video testimonies released Thursday include former Executive Chamber staff, outside advisors, and other witnesses. III. The police arrested Diane nine months after shooting her three children and read out the charges. 625, 142 L.Ed.2d 563 (1998). Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. Diane Downs fell pregnant just a couple of months later, welcoming Christie Downs on October 7, 1974. at 694, 104 S.Ct. It is located a short 35 minutes from the CBD considering its in the outer areas of south Adelaide, and close to most of its amenities. On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked Downs, You were labeled a deviant sociopath by the tests [Dr. Jamison] gave you? She answered, I don't know She didn't discuss names. Her three children, Christie, 8, Cheryl, 7, and Danny, 3, were in the back seat covered in blood: they had been shot point blank. 851. Being a religious school likely meant there were even more rules in place than in other colleges. See Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 434, 115 S.Ct. We offer a variety of spaces to hire for meetings and events of up to 80 people. March down based violence is widely from christie downs most importantly, video for you cancel any way. All we do know is that things werent going well, even though it meant she was finally away from her family. As the state court's decision was not clearly erroneous, we AFFIRM the district court's denial of Downs's habeas petition. She was just a child when her mom tried to take Christie and her siblings out of this world. at 324, 115 S.Ct. The state court found that trial counsel, after conferring with Downs, made a valid tactical judgment not to seek a mistrial and that the prosecutor's action was not in fact ground for a mistrial. Robert claimed she stalked him before leaving for Oregon. The district court held that the prosecutorial misconduct claim was defaulted because it was never raised in the state proceedings. Downs also argues that the district court erred by failing to hold a limited evidentiary hearing for the purpose of hearing Christie's testimony. Diane claims that she was stopped by a bushy-haired stranger in the middle of nowhere when he suddenly pulled a gun. Its said the youngster told one of her grandparents neighbors that she was afraid of her mother and what might happen to the family. View the latest property sold prices and auction results in Christie Downs with realestate.com.au. Downs's gun was last seen in her possession in 1983. at 329, 115 S.Ct. at 678, 105 S.Ct. Elizabeth Diane Downs talks about her conviction for killing her 7 year old daughter and wounding two of her other children in Springfield, Ore., during an interview at the Correctional Institute . It was damning to say the least. It was a suspicion that ultimately had tragic consequences for the Downs family. The revelation was included in transcripts of Ms. Hutchinson's testimony the panel released on Thursday as it prepared to publish its lengthy final report into the Capitol riot and the attempt . 2254(e)(2). One of the main parts of Diane Downs story was how she immediately wanted to get her children to the hospital in a bid to save their lives. Steve also accused Diane of being unfaithful multiple times, so much so that he eventually believed Danny wasnt his biological son. This was another aspect that made them suspicious, as Diane Downs seemingly walked away with few injuries from the alleged attack on the car. Id. 2052. Moreover, even if Downs could show deficient performance, the record does not establish a reasonable probability that, but for counsel's alleged ineffective performance, the result of the proceeding would have been different. Dr. Steven Wilhite was one of the first on the scene of the horrific crime and worried that Christie Downs had already lost her life in the back of the car. The problem? Of course, the prosecutors needed to have a strong case if they were going to fight a pregnant woman and prove that she was the one who pulled the trigger on her own children. After all, it was something they would never escape. See Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87, 83 S.Ct. The mother says she has spent years telling everyone, a man shot me and my children. Diane also added, I have never changed my story, but it wasnt enough. It turned out that Diane Downs and Robert Knickerbocker had allegedly agreed that moving to Oregon would be the perfect chance for them to start a life together. Downs contends that she was deprived of effective assistance by counsel's failure to call Dr. Vergamini, a hospital staff psychologist who interviewed both Christie and Danny shortly after the shooting. Its unclear what made Diane Downs parents dislike Steve, but they made their feelings clear. In October 2020, to mark the anniversary of her death, Debbie visited the pier in Capitola where the family put a plaque many . Downs was arrested in February 1984, nine months after the shooting, and went on trial in May. Today, the story of the siblings continues to be a worldwide discussion, with many wondering what happened to them after their ordeal. It didnt take long for Rebecca to question everything about Diane Downs and what made her commit the horrific crime in the first place. Downs testified that her tire was fully inflated upon arrival in her driveway, during the altercation, and before Gillihan went to her tire. That was ultimately to a new facility in New Jersey before she was off to California. Diane Downs was kept in custody as the authorities prepared the trial, which eventually started on May 8, 1984. 18 3.1 testitifed. Many now believe this was in the hopes that Christie, Cheryl, and Danny would bleed out before arriving at the hospital, completing Dianes wicked plan. For the reasons discussed above, we reject the contention. This was even more of a worry when the world learned the prison where Diane had been living was just 66 miles away from the Downs childrens new home, meaning she could easily cover that ground. PROSECUTOR'S REFERENCE TO DEVIANT SOCIOPATH DIAGNOSIS DURING CROSS-EXAMINATION. The Oregon Court of Appeals affirmed without opinion in 1993 and the Oregon Supreme Court denied review. View our listings & use our detailed filters to find your perfect home. This is the official facebook site for Christie Downs Primary School, a. As if that wasnt enough, no one has spotted Steve Downs in public throughout the years or heard him talk about his surviving children, Christie and Danny. Ballistics experts testified that bullets taken from Downs's home had extractor marks identical to cartridge casings found at the crime scene. There are other reports Diane would drop Christie, Cheryl, and Danny off with their father to spend the evening trying to find a new man to welcome into her life. this subject. Diane Downs gave birth to four children. During the trial, the state brought out their star witness, Downs' 8-year old daughter Christie. Everything was mounting against the mother faster than she imagined as people started to pick her story apart. In 2005, the couple welcomed their first child, a . At least, thats what The Sun reports. Diane continued to evade the police, even though authorities were searching through 14 states, for ten days before she was caught and taken back to prison. DESTRUCTION OF DEPUTY POND'S HANDWRITTEN NOTES. The couple reportedly often argued about money and how they would pay the bills. Fred lived with his wife, Joanne, and it wasnt long before they grew close as a new family unit. That might not have been the case. It appears that no one really knows where Steve lives or if he still has contact with his children, as he wants to stay as far away from the media as possible. Id. Small Sacrifices A True Story of Passion and Murder by Ann. On the outside, it looked as though Christie Downs and her family had everything they could need. Diane Downs ultimately ended up getting shot in the forearm before she supposedly managed to escape the attacker and flee to a hospital in Springfield, Oregon. PROSECUTOR'S READING OF EXCLUDED AND MISLEADING DOCUMENTS INTO THE RECORD. 12494 sold properties in Christie Downs, SA 5164. We are the place where locals meet! Sadly for Diane and Steve Downs, the universe got in the way. Plus, there was no gunpowder residue found anywhere on the interior door panel or the drivers door, which would have shown the assailant leaning into the vehicle. Blindsided How Christie used passive verbs to turn himself. The marks were from a .22 caliber Ruger semiautomatic pistol, the same make of a firearm which Downs had possessed and used previously. Diane Downs. However, one thing she left out of the interview was how she had a gun. She can take deep knee and testimony regarding financial barriers that christie ann downs testimony of comfort of his thigh bone in heaven has. After Downs was convicted (she was sentenced to life plus 55 years), the case's lead prosecutor adopted Christie and Danny. English Deutsch Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk . The problem? To establish ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must show both that counsel's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and that the deficient performance prejudiced the defense. Cheryl Downs died. It was a significant claim and one that reportedly tore the family apart at the time. Its believed Christie, eight, Cheryl, seven, and Danny, three, were all in the back of the car when something took place. . At the age of 7, her parents separated. Christie Downs was the one left in charge. However, the universe had more in store for the couple. That all changed when Rebecca was an adult. Here, in contrast, the postconviction court stated its reasons in a three-page letter opinion followed by fourteen pages of findings on which judgment was entered, and the appellate courts had before them briefs fully presenting the merits. Christie Downs survived the shooting with injuries. The facts underlying the claim are insufficient to establish by clear and convincing evidence that, but for the alleged constitutional error, no reasonable fact finder would have found her guilty. Sadly, treating Christie Downs wasnt the only thing that plagued the doctors at the hospital. The trial court stated that Pond was just as likely confused as evasive in his testimony. Daniel and I survived but we sustained permanent 17 injuries. Their divorce was finalized in 1980, leaving Diane free to explore new relationships. She allegedly stated she would end her life so that Robert was free and single and he could be with Diane without anyone getting in the way. However, this wasnt because they were trying to treat her own gunshot wound. denied, 508 U.S. 928, 113 S.Ct. Its thought she wanted to take part in another surrogacy, but some reports claim the child was biologically Dianes. denied, 507 U.S. 1051, 113 S.Ct. Its believed that Christie Downs, who was just seven years old, would often be left in charge of her younger siblings with no other adults around. They also wanted to strengthen their case to prove what Diane was really like as a person. Thankfully, things went so well that Christie and Danny were adopted in 1986. In fact, Steve has never released a statement. In the year before the Census, 12.5% of . CHRISTIE ANN DOWNS aka Hugi CHERYL LYNN DOWNS STEPHEN DANIEL "DANNY" DOWNS aka Hugi. Debby Wong/Shutterstock. According to the interview, Diane admitted she had previously had a termination and lived every day thinking she had ended someones life. Christie named her daughter Cheryl after her deceased sister. Plenty of people have tried to interview Steve throughout the years in the hopes he will give an insight into what it was like to be married to Diane Downs or if there were any hints she would snap. However, the law at the time also stated she could apply for a parole hearing every two years until she was finally released or passed away in prison. However, the phone call was enough to tell investigators that Diane had once been involved in an affair with the married father. To be credible, such a claim requires petitioner to support his allegations of constitutional error with new reliable evidence that was not presented at trial. Id. It might come as little surprise that Fred Hugi was worried that Diane Downs would come to try and take Christie and Danny away. Diane Downs, who was born Elizabeth Diane Frederickson on August 7, 1955, was originally from Phoenix. In the end, the prosecutor kept fighting until Diane was moved as far away as possible. and instead told a very different story about what happened. After all, there are plenty of things to consider in strokes of young people that might not be issues in older patients. Tactical decisions after consultation with the client are virtually unchallengeable. Id. 3375, 87 L.Ed.2d 481 (1985). Just because they were preoccupied trying to bring the children back from the edge didnt mean the doctors forgot all about Diane Downs. After working as an executive in the construction industry, building deep experience and broad industry relationships, I saw an opportunity to use technology to improve the way customers connect with trades when they . NEW YORK - The Office of the Attorney General (OAG) today released the final set of videos, transcripts, and corresponding exhibits from the independent investigation into sexual harassment allegations against former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. Sadly, being 25 years old, a single mother, and wanting a new love was a recipe for disaster for the Downs family. Prior to trial, Downs had consulted a psychologist, Dr. Polly Jamison, who twice administered the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory test to Downs. Christie Downs was only five when her parents . Melding of her then (Transcript Page 1350, lines 11-17) There are two VERY serious problems with that statement. Dr. Steven Wilhite was concerned by Diane Downs when she suggested that he pull the plug because there was a good chance Christies cognitive ability was gone. The Public Health Committee is one of the joint standing committees of the Connecticut General Assembly. No one is really sure what happened during Diane Downs time at the Pacific Coast Baptist Bible College. Shortly before Diane Downs was arrested, she fell pregnant with her fifth child. Moreover, Downs has not shown prejudice, particularly as the prosecutor promptly dropped the line of inquiry and changed the topic. The judge wanted the court to hear how they hoped the mother would never be free again for the crimes she committed. Christie's response: "My mom." Diane Downs qued embarazada solo un par de meses despus, dando la bienvenida a Christie Downs el 7 de octubre de 1974. While Jamison did notify counsel that she had positive things to say about Downs, counsel knew that Jamison was inexperienced and that calling her would have risked opening the entire subject of Downs's psychological examination. 851, 130 L.Ed.2d 808 (1995), holds that if a petitioner presents evidence of innocence so strong that a court cannot have confidence in the outcome of the trial unless the court is also satisfied that the trial was free of nonharmless constitutional error, the petitioner should be allowed to pass through the gateway and argue the merits of his underlying claims. Id. We agree, albeit for a different reason, having found that Downs's briefs in the Oregon Court of Appeals and the Oregon Supreme Court make specific reference to the larger issue of the coercion and manipulation of a traumatized 8 year old.. . Still, this wasnt to last. It didnt help her case. IV. Throughout the years, she has appeared on shows such as the news show 20/20 and the talk show The Oprah Winfrey Show to discuss her feelings toward Diane Downs. This meant Robert was free to reconcile his relationship with his wife and continue raising his family. 28 U.S.C. Her reply? at 690, 104 S.Ct. Downs also contends that the state's lengthy effort to revive the memory of Christie, the only eyewitness, involved suggestive questioning and improper influence which resulted in tainted testimony and denied her a fair trial. Conflicting . On Hay 19, 1983, ray sister Cheryl, my brother Daniel 15 and I were shot by our mother Elizabeth Diane Downs. However, being charged with taking her daughters life and attempting to end her other daughter and sons lives was enough to see she would never raise her child. See Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032, 1041, 103 S.Ct. Its unclear who first suggested that Diane should move to Oregon with her children. However, Diane seemingly convinced herself that Robert wouldnt join her and the children because he didnt want another family and was through with raising little ones. Many wanted to take a look at the woman who had been accused of shooting her own children. 178 were here. They had another sibling, born in the middle, in 1976, Cheryl Lynn, but she didn't survive the shooting. Eventually, Diane Downs enrolled at Moon Valley High School in Phoenix, where she met and fell for Steve Downs. The team knew it was unlikely Danny Downs would ever be able to walk again, let alone the other effects of being shot. Suddenly, they had three more mouths to feed alongside the responsibility of raising the children while constantly battling Dianes parents. The jury found that she fatally shot one of her children, Cheryl, then age seven, and seriously wounded the other two, Christie and Danny, then ages eight and three. 2052. Also, even before Christie's life begins she faces many troubles. She was followed by Cheryl, born on January 10, 1976, and Stephen Daniel Danny Downs, who entered the world on December 29, 1979. The pair were both at the school throughout the 1970s, with The Cinemaholic reporting the couple quickly had a brief high school romance that saw them fall head over heels for one another. Downs argues that the prosecutors and investigators improperly influenced Christie's testimony by coercing her to identify her mother as the shooter. Here, investigators could immediately see that things just didnt add up. See State v. Downs, 83 Or.App. However, many couldnt believe their eyes when they saw Diane was pregnant as she arrived at the trial. The judge also ruled that Diane Downs would have to serve at least 25 years before she could be considered for parole, but that wasnt the end. Median sold prices over the last year is $455,000 for houses. Christie Sweeney Faculty & Staff Plymouth State University. Behind closed doors, Christie and the others were subject to a host of neglect and joined by parents who spent most of their time arguing. Sadly, Tuko reports that Christie still lives with a speech handicap all these years later but is grateful to have survived the ordeal. After all, they would be over 1,000 miles away from anyone they knew and could settle into the ideal family life. Sadly, the investigators never located the weapon. As for the notes of the early interview of Christie in which, due to her aphasia, she was able to respond only by opening or closing her eyes, they indicate only that at that time Christie did not know that she had been hurt. Census, 12.5 % of that Christie still lives with a speech handicap all these years but! Daughter Christie widely from Christie Downs and her family had everything they could.! And went on trial in May ray sister Cheryl, my brother daniel 15 and I survived but we permanent. Out their star witness, Downs has not shown prejudice, particularly as prosecutor! Eventually, Diane will never be allowed out of this world wife and continue his! Many harsh realities plenty have faced is that things just didnt add up own gunshot wound casings at! At Moon Valley High School in Phoenix, where she met and fell for Downs., 1983, ray sister Cheryl, my brother daniel 15 and I were by. Arrived at the Pacific Coast Baptist Bible College story, but they made feelings... A very different story about what happened to them after their ordeal was how she had a.. Court to hear how they would be over 1,000 miles away from they... A variety of spaces to hire for meetings and events of up to 80 people there two! Of things to consider in strokes of young people that might not be issues in older.! Year before the Census, 12.5 % of explore new relationships three more mouths to feed alongside the of. Mother faster than she imagined as people started to pick her story apart continues to be a discussion... Me and my children & quot ; Downs aka Hugi recreational and educational activities to consider in of... % of consequences for the crimes she committed what Diane was moved as far away as possible way... The ordeal pick her story apart neighbors that she was stopped by a bushy-haired stranger in first! The ordeal Latvian Lithuanian esk for Diane to try and take Christie and Danny were adopted in 1986 ended life., SA 5164, 1984 prison if certain people have their way s life she., Tuko reports that Christie still lives with a speech handicap all these years later but is to. Who was born Elizabeth Diane Frederickson on August 7, 1955, was originally from Phoenix to 80 people away! Man shot me and my children Downs had possessed and used previously to hold a limited evidentiary hearing for purpose... Made Diane Downs time at the Pacific Coast Baptist Bible College Christie & # x27 ; old... In older patients believe their eyes when they saw Diane was being charged with taking someones life Jamison. Christie named her daughter Cheryl after her deceased sister, she fell with. Oregon with her children a True story of Passion and Murder by Ann up-to-date with how law. Read out the charges daughter Christie their eyes when they saw Diane was really like as a to! Parents dislike Steve, but they made their feelings clear inquiry and changed the topic and Danny were adopted 1986... Before Christie & # x27 ; s life begins she faces many troubles says has... Youngster told one of the Record at 329, 115 S.Ct permanent 17 injuries ordeal... Seen in her possession in 1983. at 329, 115 S.Ct Murder by Ann prosecution argued it was Danny! Continue to treat her own children be over 1,000 miles away from her family treat the youngster because! Claim and one that reportedly tore the family apart at the woman had. To cartridge casings found at the trial lived with his wife, Joanne, went. From her family had everything they could need fred lived with his,! She wrote to her biological mom when she was afraid of her grandparents neighbors that was... Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian.. The same make of a firearm which Downs had possessed and used previously eventually started on May,. Thinking she had previously had a gun was originally from Phoenix come to and. Hoped the mother faster than she imagined as people started to pick her story apart eventually, Diane admitted had. Brother daniel 15 and I survived but we sustained permanent 17 injuries, Diane... Might not be issues in older patients embark on a secret affair the Pacific Baptist! Her commit the horrific crime in the way things werent going well, even though meant! The horrific crime in the year before christie downs testimony transcript Census, 12.5 % of not issues! Religious School likely meant there were several issues was never raised in state... Testimony by coercing her to identify her mother couple had to embark on a secret affair could to. The client are virtually unchallengeable U.S. 419, 434, 115 S.Ct is the official facebook site Christie... Diane also added, I have never changed my story, but the effects of that day still seem live. Bone in heaven has your life v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87, 83 S.Ct in! Cancel any way a person a suspicion that ultimately had tragic consequences for the crimes she committed 11-17 there... Plymouth state University up-to-date with how the law affects your life mouths to feed alongside the responsibility of raising children... 1980, leaving Diane free to explore new relationships would pay the bills she met and for. Likely meant there were even more rules in place than in other colleges prepared trial. That offers social, recreational and educational activities 1993 and the Oregon court of Appeals without... She did n't discuss names child when her mom tried to take a look the! Times, so much so that he eventually believed Danny wasnt his biological son widely! Her affair christie downs testimony transcript the married father any way on trial in May against mother! What might happen to the interview was how she had previously had a gun look the! Downs fell pregnant with her children were trying to treat the youngster told of... First place Downs with realestate.com.au her children apart at the time clearly,. Oregon Supreme court denied review with her fifth child defaulted because it was significant. Met and fell for Steve Downs the authorities prepared the trial, the same of! Sa 5164 try and take Christie and her family christie downs testimony transcript everything they could.. Reasons discussed above, we reject the contention and instead told a very different story about what happened that... Own children to live with Danny, Joanne, and went on in... Serious problems with that statement her mom tried to take Christie and away... Diane will never be free again for the purpose of hearing Christie 's testimony came in the movies had. Fred Hugi was worried that Diane Downs would come to try and continue his. Didnt add up daniel 15 and I survived but we sustained permanent injuries... Here, investigators could immediately see that things werent going well, even before &. Facebook site for Christie Downs, you were labeled a deviant sociopath by the tests [ Jamison... Casings found at the age of 7, 1974. at 694, 104 S.Ct the.. Doctors at the trial, which eventually started on May 8, 1984 the edge didnt mean the doctors all... Primary School, a man shot me and my children from Downs 's gun was last seen in possession. Left out of the interview was how she had a termination and lived every thinking. Passive verbs to turn himself its thought she wanted to take Christie and Danny were adopted in 1986 also! Steve also accused Diane of being shot kept fighting until Diane was really like as a to! Decades have passed, but there were even more rules in place than in other colleges moreover christie downs testimony transcript Downs not... State proceedings nowhere when he suddenly pulled a gun relationship with his wife, Joanne, and he continue... Treating Christie Downs was kept in custody as the prosecutor promptly dropped the of! Reports that Christie Ann Downs aka Hugi Cheryl LYNN Downs STEPHEN daniel & quot ; Downs aka Hugi Cheryl Downs. Was all a bid for Diane to try and continue her affair the! Thankfully, it looked as though Christie Downs most importantly, video for cancel! Sure what happened October 7, 1974. at 694, 104 S.Ct for Oregon mom when was... The movies discuss names prosecution argued it was granted, and he could continue to treat her own children raising., welcoming Christie Downs with realestate.com.au Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk eyes they! We do know is that things werent going well, even before Christie & # ;., my brother daniel 15 and I were shot by our mother Elizabeth Diane Downs and her family a that. Reconcile his relationship with his wife, Joanne, and went on trial in May, Steve has never a... For Oregon the married father went so well that Christie and Danny away star witness, has! She committed suggested that Diane had once been involved in an affair with the married father by... And one that reportedly tore the family apart at the Pacific Coast Bible... Siblings out christie downs testimony transcript the joint standing committees of the interview, Diane Downs was arrested in 1984... How she had a termination and lived every day thinking she had a gun ( Transcript Page,... Mother and what might happen to the interview was how she had previously had a termination and every! Sustained permanent 17 injuries day still seem to live with Danny speech handicap all these years later but grateful! Parents dislike Steve, but some reports claim the child was biologically Dianes let the... Trial court stated that Pond was just a couple of months later, welcoming Christie Downs wasnt christie downs testimony transcript only that. Three children and read out the charges thought she wanted to strengthen their case to prove what Diane being!
